
Ybarra Maldonado Law Group
Senior Personal Injury Paralegal – Attorney & Case Strategy Support
Department: Personal Injury
Reports to: Personal Injury Attorney
Collaborates with: PI Case Directors, Paralegals, and Administrative Leadership
Case Management System: Filevine
Position Summary
Ybarra Maldonado Law Group is seeking an experienced Senior Personal Injury Paralegal to work directly alongside our Personal Injury Attorney in managing substantive casework, evaluating claims, preparing settlement demands, supporting negotiations, and identifying litigation risks.
This individual will serve as a trusted partner to the attorney, bringing strong personal injury knowledge, sound judgment, and proactive case management skills to ensure cases are thoroughly evaluated and efficiently advanced toward resolution.
The Senior PI Paralegal will collaborate with PI Case Directors and administrative leadership to maintain visibility into case progression, identify cases requiring attorney attention, and ensure that important case decisions are made in a timely manner.
The ideal candidate is highly experienced in pre-litigation personal injury, understands how to evaluate case strengths and weaknesses, and can help the attorney make informed decisions regarding settlements, case viability, and potential litigation.
Key Responsibilities
1. Attorney Support & Case Strategy
Serve as the primary senior paralegal supporting the Personal Injury Attorney.
Work directly with the attorney on case evaluations, settlement preparation, and litigation considerations.
Analyze liability, medical treatment, damages, insurance coverage, and case strengths and weaknesses.
Prepare detailed case summaries and recommendations for attorney review.
Assist the attorney in developing negotiation approaches and evaluating settlement opportunities.
Provide practical insight into insurance adjuster practices, claims handling, and PI settlement procedures.
Help the attorney maintain visibility into the status of active cases, pending decisions, and upcoming milestones.
Anticipate case-related issues and proactively prepare information needed for attorney decisions.
2. Settlement & Negotiation Support
Draft and prepare comprehensive settlement demand packages.
Review medical records, medical bills, treatment histories, and supporting documentation.
Analyze settlement offers and prepare proposed counteroffers for attorney consideration.
Assist the attorney with evaluating potential settlement ranges and negotiation considerations.
Identify opportunities to strengthen demands and address weaknesses in presented claims.
Prepare settlement summaries, damages calculations, and negotiation materials.
Assist with lien reductions, settlement breakdowns, and resolution-related documentation.
Track assigned negotiations and ensure timely attorney follow-up.
3. Case Viability, Drops & Statute-of-Limitations Review
Proactively identify cases with weak liability, insufficient damages, causation issues, limited coverage, or other viability concerns.
Review cases for potential settlement, closure, or litigation considerations.
Identify cases that may not justify the expense or risk of litigation and present concerns to the attorney early.
Help ensure cases requiring potential withdrawal or closure are identified well before applicable statutes of limitations.
Monitor critical deadlines relevant to attorney case evaluations and decisions.
Collaborate with PI Case Directors to obtain updated case information and confirm relevant deadlines.
Prepare case viability summaries to support timely attorney decisions.
Assist with implementing attorney-approved settlement, litigation, or case closure decisions.
Immediately escalate approaching deadlines and unresolved case risks to the attorney.
Ensure case closures and withdrawals are handled under attorney direction with appropriate notice and protection of client interests.
4. Case Progression & Attorney Workflow Visibility
Help the attorney maintain an organized understanding of the active PI caseload.
Review Filevine case statuses, upcoming deadlines, pending demands, settlement offers, and cases requiring decisions.
Identify cases that appear stalled or require additional legal evaluation.
Coordinate with PI Case Directors to obtain updates and resolve case-specific issues.
Prepare attorney case review agendas and summaries of matters requiring immediate attention.
Follow up on substantive tasks assigned by the attorney.
Anticipate upcoming demands, negotiations, and litigation decisions.
Collaborate with administrative leadership regarding workflow-related concerns or support needs.
Help ensure the attorney’s substantive priorities are communicated and addressed without assuming departmental management responsibilities.
5. Collaboration With PI Case Directors & Paralegals
Work alongside PI Case Directors and paralegals responsible for day-to-day case management.
Collaborate on gathering medical records, billing information, insurance documentation, and evidence.
Communicate case-specific documentation needs and attorney requests.
Support complex case evaluations and settlement preparation.
Help identify cases ready for attorney review, demand preparation, or negotiations.
Coordinate follow-up on substantive case needs while respecting established responsibilities.
Maintain open communication to promote efficient case progression.
6. Litigation Preparation & Case Transitions
Assist the attorney with evaluating cases for potential litigation.
Prepare organized case summaries, liability evidence, medical chronologies, and damages documentation.
Identify missing evidence or unresolved issues before litigation decisions.
Assist with attorney-directed litigation preparation.
Coordinate necessary case information with PI Case Directors.
Support appropriate transitions between pre-litigation, litigation, settlement, and closure.
Required Qualifications
Minimum 5 years of personal injury paralegal experience.
Strong Arizona pre-litigation personal injury experience preferred.
Demonstrated experience preparing demands and supporting settlement negotiations.
Strong understanding of liability, damages, insurance coverage, and case valuation.
Experience identifying case viability issues and litigation risks.
Strong knowledge of statute-of-limitations tracking and deadline management.
Ability to work independently while collaborating closely with attorneys and case teams.
Excellent analytical, organizational, and communication skills.
Filevine experience strongly preferred.
Bilingual English/Spanish preferred.
Key Performance Indicators
Quality and timeliness of attorney case evaluations.
Accuracy and completeness of settlement demand packages.
Effective preparation for attorney negotiations.
Early identification and escalation of nonviable cases.
Timely identification of approaching statutes of limitations.
Consistent completion of attorney-assigned substantive tasks.
Clear visibility into cases requiring attorney decisions.
Strong collaboration with PI Case Directors and administrative leadership.
Accurate documentation in Filevine.
Role Expectations
The Senior Personal Injury Paralegal is expected to be proactive, analytical, organized, and comfortable working closely with an attorney in a fast-paced personal injury practice.
The individual must be capable of recognizing potential case concerns, anticipating attorney needs, and taking ownership of assigned substantive paralegal work.
This position is collaborative and hands-on, rather than a departmental management role. All legal strategy, settlement decisions, litigation decisions, and other matters requiring attorney judgment remain under the authority of the supervising attorney.
Pay: $50,000.00 - $60,000.00 per year
Work Location: In person
You'll be redirected to Ybarra Maldonado Law Group's application page.
Medical Malpractice Paralegal
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith LLP · Phoenix, AZ
Medical Malpractice Paralegal
Lewis Brisbois · Phoenix, AZ
Personal Injury Litigation Paralegal- REMOTE/WFH
Parnall Law · Phoenix, AZ
Paralegal - Pre-Litigation
Ramos Law · Phoenix, AZ
Senior Personal Injury Paralegal – Attorney & Case Strategy Support
Ybarra Maldonado Law Group · Phoenix, AZ
Apply NowApply on Ybarra Maldonado Law Group's site
Senior Personal Injury Paralegal – Attorney & Case Strategy Support
Ybarra Maldonado Law Group